Autoformer Volume Control FAQ
Q - What is an autoformer?
A - An autoformer (short for autotransformer) is a special type of transformer with an especially simple winding arraignment. The simplicity means that it can't be substituted for an ordinary transformer in most applications, but when it can be used the result is a device with higher performance.
To be more specific, an ordinary transformer has separate primary (input) and secondary (output) windings, while an autoformer shares some part of the winding between the two.
Note that the ordinary transformer provides DC isolation between the input and output windings. In many applications this is an important feature. However, when DC isolation is not required then an autoformer will often outperform an ordinary transformer. This is because virtually all electronic devices exhibit some imperfections; they are not ideal. But compared to an ordinary transformer, an autoformer can often be made with fewer (or smaller) imperfections. The behavior of an autoformer is often closer to ideal.
You might have noticed that the autoformer is a simple three-terminal device with a common ground. This makes it a direct replacement for resistive voltage dividers like potentiometers or stepped attenuators.
Q - Why use an autoformer volume control? I've been happy with a good quality potentiometer.
A - The simple answer is that most people find that the autoformer volume control sounds significantly better than even the best potentiometer or stepped attenuator. And it's not a subtle difference; most people report that the autoformer has such an open, effortless sound that they would not consider going back to a resistive device.
Exactly why they sound better is still under debate, but one theory is that it's because an autoformer doesn't attenuate by wasting energy. A fairly good analogy can be made to the transmission in a car. If you need to drive at a slow steady speed which method would you choose: (1) leave the transmission in high gear and apply the brakes to keep from going too fast, or (2) downshift into a lower gear that will allow the car to go the desired speed with minimum effort?
An autoformer is essentially an electronic gearbox that operates without wasting significant energy. Potentiometers and stepped attenuators adjust the signal level by literally turning the excess signal into heat. On the other hand, when an autoformer is adjusted for low volume level it actually makes things easier for the source, much like a low gear makes things easy for your car engine.
becomes quickly apparent that the reflective load can be ignored in
this case since it is many multiples of the inductance in parallel with
it. Inductance gives you a impedance = 2*pi*Frequncy*L(inductance) or
Z=2piFL. Its this simple formula that tells you what you need to know
about the impedance presented ot the source.
Q - What is the impedance presented to the source?
A - It is the reflected load in parallel with the inductive reactance of the autoformer. When set for no attenuation, the reflected load is simply whatever follows the volume control in the signal chain. However, that load is cut in half (resistance is doubled) for every 3dB of attenuation. At -20dB the reflected load is reduced by a factor of 100. At -40dB it is reduced by a factor of 10,000 which is 10,000 times the resistance!
simplified approach is to determine the desired load taking into consideration
the lowest frequency of interest and doing a few simple calculations.
For example: If your source is a CD player with a 50 ohm Z-out and you
want to adhere to the 1:10 ratio of source to load many suggest all
you nee d ot do is pick a suitable low frequency (often 20hz)
and plug the numbers into the Z=2piFL formula to get, 500=2*pi*20*L.
Solving for L gives you a required 4hy inductance to provide a 500 ohm
load to a 50 ohm source.
The simplified approach is to determine the desired load taking into consideration the lowest frequency of interest and doing a few simple calculations. For example: If your source is a CD player with a 50 ohm Z-out and you want to adhere to the 1:10 ratio of source to load many suggest all you nee
d ot do is pick a suitable low frequency (often 20hz) and plug the numbers into the Z=2piFL formula to get, 500=2*pi*20*L. Solving for L gives you a required 4hy inductance to provide a 500 ohm load to a 50 ohm source.
Autoformers come shipped with a butt gap which provides approximately
20hy's of inductance. If your situation requires more inductance it
is quite simple to restack the lams
to get inductance values up to 170hy's.
to get inductance values up to 170hy's.
Q - What if I don't want to stack the lams?
A - They come stacked with a butt-joint , but stacking a core is not a difficult job and takes only a few minutes.
- What if I bend some of the lams ?
A - Much has been said about how delicate nickel lams are. In our experinces we have found that the bending of a few lams doesn't seem to effect the performance of the core. We have autoformers in the field that have been restacked dozens of times wiht no detectable change in the cores behavior. In any event with just a little care this is not an issue. We do offer replacement cores for a small charge.
Q- How do I hook them up?
A- Check out the AVC Wiring page
Q - What is the core material.?
A - HyMu 80
Q - How does it differ from permalloy and mumetall?
A - The difference is primarily in the spelling, though mumetal contains a little more copper making it better for shielding. Permalloy and Mumetal were once trade names owned by their manufacturer but today like Kleenex and Xerox they have become generic phrases. HyMu 80 Is the actual core material we use.
Q- Do I need to shield the autoformers from external fields?
A - In most cases, careful layout and construction makes this unnecessary. Preferably, they should not share a chassis with other transformers. If your layout or environment makes shielding necessary, we do offer shielding materials. Typically, placing the autoformer in the 'shadow' of a single piece of foil is sufficient to shield from 50/60Hz hum. Rarely is it necessary to completely enclose the device. Because the foil has a very high magnetic permeability it should not be placed as far as practical from the autoformers, preferably at least 1/2 inch. A little experimentation might be necessary...
Q - Isn't 14 steps an odd number?
A - You got a problem with the number 14? Seriously, the 14 pin PC mount bobbins make the manufacture especially easy which brings the cost down for everyone. In truth there are 15 steps if you consider full volume and 16 if you consider off as a position. We can custom wind autoformers with virtually any number of taps desired, up to a realistic maximum .
Q - What kind of switch should I use?
- Any shorting (make before break) switch will work. We obtained a small
quantity of surplus 17 position switches and will include one free of
charge as long as our supply lasts. Otherwise, we have been very happy
with the Elma 04-1130(or 04-1100.) A 12 position shorting switch can
be used if 12 taps are selected. Or, you can develop a good system using
relays and share your design with the rest of the DIY community.
:-) The kits at Dantimax
look very interesting.
The kits at Dantimax look very interesting.
Q - Why not attach leadout wires?
A - The PC mount bobbin eases manufacture and makes them more economical. The winding is still one continuous piece of magnet wire. Of course, we can always wind custom units with integral leadout wires, but it's not recommended unless you have additional requirements.
Q - Aren't 3db steps rather coarse?
A - For some reason (that we don't understand) 3dB steps on a magnetic attenuator seem finer than the same size steps on a resistive device. In any case, few people find this configuration inadequate.
Q - What is the frequency response?
- The frequency response on the low end is determined by the ratio of
the chosen inductance and the output
impedance of the source. The frequency where the Zout of the source
= 2*pi*F*L the response will be -3dB. The -1db point will happen at
double the frequency of the -3dB point. The top end behavior reamins
consistant with any stacking method and exceeds 200khz on all attenuation
settings. Click the image below for an animation of both the frequency
response to 600khz and 10K square wave performance of an autoformer
at each volume setting . Please note that the settings in red represent
the unit wired for +3dB and +6dB of gain.
. Please note that the settings in red represent the unit wired for +3dB and +6dB of gain.
Q - What is the maximum input voltage
A - 8V@20hz
Q - what if I need more than 42db of attenuation.
A - Custom units can be wound to 54dB of attenuation. Note that that is a 500:1 stepdown and may compromise the performance slightly. If you require that much attenuation you might want to examine the gain structure of your system.
Q - Can the units be wired for gain,?
A - Yes, some people report good results but be aware that wiring for 6dB of gain means that the source will see only 1/4 the inductance of the full winding. Stacking the core with more interleave will recover the lost inductance, though the ultimate success may depend on your system and your requirements. It is also important to note the behavior of the device when used for gain might not make measurement conscious people very happy. We encourage experimentation and appreciate any and all feedback.
Q - Do I need to load the secondary?
A - No, it is not necessary. But this shouldn't stop you from experimenting. You might find that you prefer some additional load.
Q - What about a balance control?
A - A potentiometer could be added to apply different loads to the two channels, but we do not recommended it. If you find the need for a balance control then we recommend that you investigate your room layout and speaker placement. A little rearrangement will probably make you a lot happier.
Q - Will they work for balanced attenuation.?
A - They have been used with good results in balanced systems but it requires two autoformers per channel. It is also be possible to custom build autoformers with both windings on a single core to take advantage of the magnetic coupling between windings.
Q - Can it be used with solid state,?
A - Absolutely. The lower output impedance generally makes for a very good match. Recent feedback suggests that the benefits in a solid state system seem to be greater than in tubed systems.
Q - What if I don't like the sound?
A - We are proud to say that very few people have been anything less than thrilled by the sound. We are also proud to say that the few customers that have tried to sell their units have had no trouble at all.
That's about it for now, please check out the forum for more information.